Selective Company Awards

Since Selective’s inception, our team of talented professionals has won multiple industry honors and ratings for our commitment to superior financial strength, innovative product and services, and an inclusive employee experience.

We take great pride in our unwavering devotion to providing our unique customers and agency partners with a best-in-class insurance experience, and are honored to have received such awards and recognitions.

Below you will find a few award highlights that further display what it means to Be Uniquely Insured.

Great Place To Work-Certified™ in 2020

Selective announced that it is Great Place to Work-Certified™. Great Place to Work® is the global authority on workplace culture, employee experience, and the leadership behaviors proven to deliver market-leading revenue and increased innovation. Selective employees resoundingly responded to the survey with positive marks for the company, with 91% of respondents validating Selective as a great place to work.

Insurance Business America's Top Insurance Workplace

Selective has been named a “Top Insurance Workplace” by Insurance Business America (IBA). IBA’s annual Top Insurance Workplaces list recognizes employers for their outstanding performance in establishing workplaces where employees can thrive, enjoy their work and help their companies grow.

DiversityJobs Top Employer for 2020

Selective was recognized by DiversityJobs as one of their Top Employers for 2020 for showing continual dedication and commitment to establishing a diverse workforce and culture.

Best Mobile App Design

The MySelective mobile app is a winner of 2020 Summer Awards for Best Mobile App Design. This award recognizes the best-designed, most intuitive, creative and unique mobile interface design.

Insurance Business Global 100

Selective President and CEO, John Marchioni was selected for the annual 2021 Insurance Business Global 100. Now in its second year, this formidable list of the biggest names in insurance was put together by Insurance Business to shine a spotlight on outstanding industry professionals who are making a positive difference and helping drive change across the sector.

NJ Herald’s Readers’ Choice Awards

The readers of the New Jersey Herald, one of North Jersey’s largest newspapers, voted Selective their insurance carrier of choice - outranking runners-up State Farm and Allstate.

Years Received: 2019, 2020

Insurance Business Global 100

Year Received: 2020

ACORD Leadership Award

Selective received two honors from the Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development (ACORD). The ACORD Leadership Award is in recognition of our leadership in the areas of standards development, advocacy, implementation, and for going above and beyond in guiding the insurance industry towards greater clarity in the sharing of insurance data.

Year Received: 2020

ACORD Millennial Women’s Insurance Advancement Award

Selective received two honors from the Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development (ACORD). The ACORD Millennial Women’s Insurance Advancement Award was given to Selective for making impressive strides in attracting and retaining millennials within the insurance industry.

Year Received: 2020

Digital Insurer Honors from IVANS

IVANS®, a division of Applied Systems®, recently recognized Selective as one of its IVANS Connected Agency and Digital Insurer recipients at its IVANS Connect conference in September. The Digital Insurer awards honor insurers for excellence in their ability to create a more profitable and valuable distribution channel for independent agents through increased connectivity and automated data exchange. Selective received the Gold Award in the Personal Lines category for being in the top percentile of digital technology adoption when compared to our peers. Selective also received the Silver Award in the Commercial Lines category.

Year Received: 2020

Best Mobile App Design

The MySelective mobile app is a winner of 2020 Summer Awards for Best Mobile App Design. This award recognizes the best-designed, most intuitive, creative and unique mobile interface design.

Year Received: 2020

Super Regional P/C Insurers by Insurance Journal

Insurance Journal named Selective one of the nation’s top P&C insurers when they classified our team on the “Super Regional Property/Casualty Insurer” list. This list is reserved for P&C insurers who have successfully written several lines of insurance in multiple states.

Years Received: 2019, 2020

AON Ward’s 50

Our team is proud to be recognized by AON Ward as a top performing P&C insurer. As a Ward’s 50 listed company, Selective passed all safety and consistency screens, and achieved superior performance over a five year period (2015-2019).

Years Received: 2019, 2020

Insurance Business America's Top Insurance Workplace

Year Received: 2020

2020 Gold Stevie Award

Selective’s Diversity & Inclusion video was named winner of the 2020 Gold Stevie® Award in the Social Video category in the 18th Annual American Business Awards®. The American Business Awards are the U.S.A.’s premier business awards program. Nicknamed the “Stevies” for the Greek word meaning “crowned,” more than 3,600 nominations from organizations of all sizes and in virtually every industry were submitted this year for consideration in a wide range of categories. About 35% of the 3,600 nominations considered became Stevie winners, including Selective!

Year Received: 2020

Fortune 1000

Selective secured a spot among the top performing companies, based on revenues, when Fortune business magazine ranked our team #839 in 2019 and #814 in 2020 on the annual Fortune 1000 list. This prestigious list signals the continuous growth and successful operations of companies awarded such a position.

Years Received: 2019, 2020

DiversityJobs Top Employer for 2020

Selective was recognized by DiversityJobs as one of their Top Employers for 2020 for showing continual dedication and commitment to establishing a diverse workforce and culture.

Year Received: 2020

2020 Confirmit's ACE Award

Selective has been awarded a 2020 Confirmit Achievement in Customer Excellence (ACE) Award in the Voice of the Customer (VoC) category. This recognition validates all the hard work and commitment from our front-line employees to ensure our customers' experience with Selective is as seamless, efficient and productive as possible. Selective also recently won this award in 2018 and 2017.

Year Received: 2020

Great Place To Work-Certified™ in 2020

Year Received: 2020

Forbes America’s Best Mid-Size Employers

Selective was thrilled when Forbes ranked our team #79 out of 500, one of the top P&C insurers, on the 2019 list of America’s Best Midsize Employers. This award acknowledges our commitment to employing a diverse team that feels valued in their contributions to the unique communities we serve.

Year Received: 2019

2019 Business Insurance Innovation Award

Selective was honored with the 2019 Innovation Award from Business Insurance for Selective Drive®, the commercial fleet management tool. This award acknowledges our leadership, ingenuity, and inventiveness with the introduction of Selective Drive® to the risk management community.

Year Received: 2019

2019 Big I NY Outstanding Carrier Award

Selective received the Outstanding Company Partner Award from the Big I of New York, which recognized our investment in building stronger partnerships, delivering best-in-class service, and providing superior support to our agency partners in New York.

Year Received: 2019

2019 PIA National Company Award of Excellence

The National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA) honored Selective by naming us the recipient of the 2019 PIA National Company Award of Excellence. This award symbolizes our commitment to the PIA, the American Agency System, and creating a better business environment for professional insurance agents.

Year Received: 2019

2019 PIANJ Company of the Year

The Professional Insurance Agents of New Jersey (PIANJ) presented Selective with their prestigious Company of the Year award for our team’s premier standing in the PIANJ and our relentless dedication to our agency partners.

Year Received: 2019

Professional Insurance Agents (PIA) of Indiana

2019 PIA of Indiana Company Person of the Year

Victoria Learned-Fenty, Selective Management Liability Underwriting Specialist, was named 2019 Company Person of the Year by the Professional Insurance Agents (PIA) of Indiana. This award honors an employee who has excelled as an insurance professional and demonstrated the highest ethical and service standards.

Year Received: 2019